Slack was a budget line
One kinked cable stopped the railway between Rotterdam and Breda for a week. Reserve capacity is a physical asset that no budget records as an asset, which is why it is the first thing to go.
In early July a feeder cable for the overhead line near Rotterdam Stadion station sat in a kink, possibly because the dried-out ground had subsided. Resistance rose, heat built up, and then there was a fire. Over 20 metres, 299 cables were damaged. For a week no train ran between Rotterdam and Breda, and Brussels and Paris could be reached only by way of Utrecht. The Dutch daily NRC described it as a system without reserve and put it in a row: a railway bridge in Zeeland that warped in the heat, a viaduct on the A16 motorway closed to heavy traffic because of hairline cracks in the steel, Schiphol airport brought to a standstill in January by a few days of snow because de-icing capacity fell short.
The word that returns in all these cases is slack. It deserves more precise treatment than it usually gets, because slack is a quantity. A second feeder route, points that are heated although it rarely freezes, a week of margin between the renovation of one bridge and the next tunnel. These are physical things that cost money to keep and that yield nothing in an ordinary year.
That is the problem. In a budget, reserve capacity appears as cost. Its return falls only in the year something goes wrong, and then it lands with passengers and operators, in the form of a delay that did not happen. No set of accounts records a failure that failed to occur. A manager who optimises every year for thirty years therefore removes a little slack each round and sees a saving each time. The bill arrives all at once, on a day in July, in somebody else’s name.
Since this year ProRail, the Dutch rail infrastructure manager, maintains the network at a “basic quality level” agreed with the state, which the manager itself describes as the minimum needed to keep trains running. Rijkswaterstaat, the national roads and waterways agency, works with the same construct. The term sounds like a floor. In practice it has become the target, since anything above the minimum is by definition room that can still be given up. ProRail’s departing chief executive put it this way in December: cutting maintenance looks like a saving, but it is a shift.
It helps to see it as a loan. Deferred maintenance is money borrowed from the structure, at an interest rate nobody knows and which rises as the structure ages. Up to 2040 the Dutch cabinet is more than 80 billion euros short for maintenance, renewal and construction. Many bridges, locks and viaducts date from the 1950s and 1960s and reach the end of their design life in the same years. The renovation of the Afsluitdijk, the 32-kilometre dam that closes off the IJsselmeer, was budgeted at 550 million euros and planned for 2022; it is now expected in 2030.
The underlying error is one of units. Infrastructure is budgeted by the year and fails by the decade. An annual budget cannot see a sixty-year bridge; it sees only this year’s maintenance line, and that line can always be postponed. In the same article Bert van Wee, emeritus professor of transport policy at Delft University of Technology, notes that politicians score with new projects and rarely with upkeep, and that an unexpected delay hurts more per hour than an expected one. Both remarks say the same thing: the system rewards what is visible within the term.
What would help is to make slack itself visible, as a quantity alongside the budget. What share of the network has a second route. How many weeks of margin lie between major renovations. What share of structures is past its design life, and how that share changes per year. These are numbers a manager has or can produce, and they belong on the table in parliament next to the amount. A minister who gives up slack should then have to say so in the unit in which the loss falls.
Before the summer the cabinet presented an assessment framework with the same logic: maintenance before new construction, replacement only where unavoidable. According to critics, some 75 renewal projects will be left waiting as a result. The question of where the money should come from went unanswered in the parliamentary debate at the end of June; the cabinet does not intend to discuss it until the end of the year. I would put a second question next to it: how much slack will the network still have in five years, and who signed that number.
Source: Jan Benjamin, “Eén brandje langs het spoor legt het halve treinverkeer plat. De rek is eruit in de Nederlandse infrastructuur”, NRC, 3 July 2026: the incident, the examples, the basic quality level of ProRail (since 2026) and Rijkswaterstaat, the shortfall of more than 80 billion euros up to 2040, the Afsluitdijk, the assessment framework and the quotations from John Voppen and Bert van Wee. According to the same source, Rijkswaterstaat’s warning of a “critical limit” dates from late 2025.