House of Viridian
← Limbic Literacy
· Commentary

The Determinant Gets an Address

Since 4 October, The Lancet counts digital design among the determinants of health, moving attention away from blaming the user and towards the governance of the structure. On a word with a history, and on two rulings that show where the obligation then lands.

On 4 October 2026, The Lancet published a Series on the digital determinants of health. (1) The governance paper in that Series contains a sentence worth copying out. A public health approach, write Barbara Prainsack, Rohinton Medhora and Ilona Kickbusch, shifts attention away from individual responsibility and from the tendency to blame users, towards the governance of the structural features that produce health risks and inequities. (2)

Kickbusch chaired the 2021 commission of The Lancet and the Financial Times on growing up in a digital world. (3) Five years on, that work takes the form of a determinant.

The word has a history. Determinants of health are the conditions under which people live: what they eat, where they live, how they work. Since 2023 the field has worked with commercial determinants within that category — the systems, practices and pathways through which commercial actors influence health and equity, inside an arrangement that lets those actors cause harm and externalise its costs. (4) This week’s Series places digital infrastructure, business models and design choices in the same category, across four governance domains: infrastructure and access, platform design and commercial practices, data governance and surveillance, and institutional accountability and rights. (2)

What separates this from an opinion piece is the toolkit. A determinant of health falls under public health policy, and that field has liability, product safety and regulation as working categories.

The figure, named precisely

How an industry relocates responsibility has been studied. In 2015, Lissy Friedman and four colleagues at Northeastern University analysed the rhetoric of the tobacco industry in public relations and in the courtroom. (5) Their finding is more precise than the cliché. The industry rarely uses the term “personal responsibility”. It says “freedom of choice”. In litigation that phrase means the smoker alone caused the injury. In public campaigns the same phrase means liberty, as a right. One formulation performs two jobs, and the blame rhetoric from the courtroom colours the public story.

This is the figure I earlier called the limbic alibi: an outcome made possible by a sequence of decisions, attributed to the person who ends up with it. (6) The tobacco literature describes it fifteen years earlier, with the documents attached.

Where the obligation then sits

In the same year, two places showed what it looks like when the address changes.

On 6 August 2026, Judge Bryan Biedscheid in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay 567 million dollars. He called the platforms a public nuisance and a significant contributing cause of the youth mental health crisis in the state. Of that sum, 420 million goes to treatment, the remainder to prevention, screening and awareness, spread over five years. It comes on top of 375 million dollars in civil penalties imposed by a jury in March. (7) The remedies the judge added concern design: in New Mexico, Meta may send no push notifications to the accounts of minors between ten at night and seven in the morning, and must cap their use at ninety hours a month. Meta is appealing.

On 10 December 2025, a minimum age of sixteen came into force in Australia for accounts on a listed set of platforms. (8) The obligation sits with the provider, which must take reasonable steps to keep those accounts off the platform; failure can bring a penalty of up to 49.5 million Australian dollars. Parents cannot consent around it. By mid-December the platforms had removed 4.7 million accounts held by under-sixteens.

Note the address in both cases. The obligation comes to rest with the party that built the design, and the sanction is aimed at that party.

What this does not prove

Whether the Australian measure improves the health of young people is unknown. The law is too young for that. The measure itself is contested, and age verification brings problems of its own, from enforceability to the data it requires. (9) The point here concerns the placement of the obligation, rather than proven effect.

That distinction only becomes available once there are data. Which is why European enforcement belongs in the same story. On 24 October 2025 the European Commission preliminarily found TikTok and Meta in breach of their transparency obligations under the Digital Services Act, including the access that Article 40 gives researchers to public data. (10) Without that access, the evidence needed to measure a determinant does not exist, and the burden of proof returns to the user.

Until now the diagnosis had no address. As of this week it has a field behind it, with the instruments that belong to that field.


(1) The Lancet Series on the digital determinants of health, published 4 October 2026. The Series opens with James Shaw et al., “The digital determinants of health: a new era for global public health,” The Lancet, online 4 October 2026, doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(26)01292-4.

(2) Barbara Prainsack, Rohinton P. Medhora and Ilona Kickbusch, “Governing the digital determinants of health for children and young people: a global public health imperative,” The Lancet, online 4 October 2026, doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(26)01293-6. The quoted sentence and the four governance domains appear in the summary.

(3) Ilona Kickbusch et al., “The Lancet and Financial Times Commission on governing health futures 2030: growing up in a digital world,” The Lancet 398 (2021): 1727–1776.

(4) Anna B. Gilmore et al., “Defining and conceptualising the commercial determinants of health,” The Lancet 401, no. 10383 (8 April 2023): 1194–1213.

(5) Lissy C. Friedman, Andrew Cheyne, Daniel Givelber, Mark A. Gottlieb and Richard A. Daynard, “Tobacco Industry Use of Personal Responsibility Rhetoric in Public Relations and Litigation: Disguising Freedom to Blame as Freedom of Choice,” American Journal of Public Health 105, no. 2 (2015): 250–260.

(6) See The Limbic Alibi (House of Viridian, Limbic Literacy, 21 August 2026).

(7) State of New Mexico v. Meta Platforms; ruling by Judge Bryan Biedscheid, 6 August 2026. See the reporting by NPR and Al Jazeera of 6 and 7 August 2026, and Lucy Taylor, “Meta and Google are found liable for harm to child’s mental health in landmark ruling,” BMJ 392 (2026): s602.

(8) Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Act 2024, passed 28 November 2024, in force 10 December 2025. Listed platforms and enforcement: eSafety Commissioner, “Social media age restrictions”. The figure of 4.7 million removed accounts was reported by eSafety on 16 January 2026.

(9) See among others Jameson Fardouly, “Potential effects of the social media age ban in Australia for children younger than 16 years,” The Lancet Digital Health 7 (2025): e235–e236, and Fatma Eltaher et al., “The digital loophole: evaluating the effectiveness of child age verification methods on social media,” in Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Information Systems Security and Privacy, vol. 2 (SciTePress, 2025), 213–222.

(10) European Commission, “Commission preliminarily finds TikTok and Meta in breach of their transparency obligations under the Digital Services Act,” press release, 24 October 2025. The findings are preliminary and do not prejudge the outcome of the investigation.