The 'Money Wife' Tradition and Child Brides in Cross River
Some practices say more about systems than about individuals.
I read once about the “money wife” practice in Cross River, Nigeria. This is a case where a woman takes a role not traditionally female. She pays the bride price. She marries a woman. She is the “man” in the relationship in every formal sense.
This was not shameful. This was a way for women to have power in a system where women had no power. This was a workaround.
What strikes me is this: the system was so restrictive that women had to find a way to work through the system. They stopped being women. They became men in the eyes of the system. This is not freedom. This is navigating unfreedom.
There is also the case of child brides in the same region. Young girls are married to much older men. This is not sex, at first. This is: the child stays until she is grown. But the relationship is established.
Why does this happen? Not because parents are cruel. But because: poverty. Economic uncertainty. Bonds between families. This system guarantees that a girl will have food and protection.
Is this good? No. But it is understandable. It is not about individuals. It is about systems that create poverty and then produce practices to work around it.
If you want these practices to stop, do not combat poverty alone. Combat the system of restriction. Give women power. Then these practices disappear.
This is important because it means that moralizing does not help. Western countries can tell Nigeria: how unethical! But if Nigeria says: help our economy, help women become entrepreneurs, then real change happens.
What always strikes me about these kinds of practices is that we direct blame at individuals. “Those parents should not marry off their daughter!” True. But why do they do it? Because they need the money. Because the system offers no alternatives.
This applies to many practices. Women in textile work under bad conditions. Not because the factory owner is evil, but because that is the only work available. Children in mining. Not because miners are monsters, but because that is the only income.
Systems create practices. Practices create individuals who execute them. You cannot change individuals without changing systems.
This does not mean that individuals have no responsibility. It means that system change takes priority over individual blame.
Sources: Anthropological research on family structures in Nigeria; Rachel Kranton, The Making of Modern Marriage; Esther Duflo on poverty and practices.