The rules of conversation
In 44 BC Cicero wrote down how to talk at table. The list has barely changed since.
The Economist’s 2006 Christmas issue carries an essay on the art of conversation that I reread from time to time. The claim is small and far-reaching: the rules for good conversation are remarkably stable. Not stable since the 1950s, but for two thousand years.
In De officiis Cicero observed that everyone had written down rules for public speaking and nobody for ordinary conversation. So he did it himself. Speak clearly. Speak easily, but not too much, certainly not when someone else wants a turn. Do not interrupt. Be courteous. Treat serious matters seriously and light ones lightly. Do not criticise people behind their backs. Stay on subjects that concern everyone. Do not talk about yourself. And above all: never lose your temper.
Read that list again and consider that it predates the common era. Two are missing, The Economist writes, and they are just as old: remember a person’s name, and listen properly. In 1936 Dale Carnegie turned those into a book that sold fifteen million copies and is still in print. His six ways to be liked are Cicero in an American jacket: be genuinely interested, smile, remember names, listen, talk about what the other person cares about, and make them feel important.
What I like here is the conclusion the essay draws. If the advice stays nearly identical across twenty centuries and dozens of cultures, then these are not manners but something harder: there really is right and wrong in a conversation. It is not etiquette, it is a grammar.
I wrote earlier about the pub as a practice room and the piazza as a design that arose through use. This is the missing piece: those places work because a grammar applies at the table that nobody invented and everybody recognises. At a table where one person is not listening, the place is worth nothing.
The nicest detail comes from the other side. Churchill was, according to the essay, perhaps the greatest talker of the twentieth century, and often a poor listener. Being brilliant, then, is not enough. Cicero’s last rule still weighs heaviest.
Source: “Chattering classes: the rules for verbal exchanges are surprisingly enduring”, The Economist, 23 December 2006 (Christmas issue, pages 51-54), with Cicero, De officiis (44 BC) and Dale Carnegie, How to Win Friends and Influence People (Simon & Schuster, 1936).