The Moment of Seeing
Jean-Paul Sartre on what you see when you truly see, in a Parisian coffee shop.
Sartre described in Nausea a moment in a café. The protagonist sits with coffee, and suddenly all meaning disappears. The things are still there. The table, the cup, the floor. But their names vanish. Their meaning vanishes. He sees them simply. And that seeing, that is nausea. Because you suddenly realize that you normally always look through layers of filter.
This moment is not mystical. It is deliberate perception. It is what happens when you are conscious of your own seeing. And in that moment you discover that what you called “seeing,” was not seeing at all. It was recognizing. It was assigning meaning. It was filling the world with your own interpretation.
This touches artwork. Because artwork is that moment. Artwork says: look without your automatic meaning-giving. Look at what is actually there, not at what you think it is.
A painting by Agnes Martin, with her fine lines, can seem like nothing up close. Bands of colour. No recognition. No meaning. But as you see it, without assigning it meaning, then suddenly it is there. You feel something. Not because you understand it. Because you see it.
Much artwork fails because artists try to stay close to understanding. They want you to understand it. But the best artwork expels understanding. It says: you do not get this, and that is good. Look at what it is without interpreting it.
Sartre said that nausea is simultaneously horrible and liberating. Horrible because you realize you never really look. Liberating because now you can. Now you can choose how you see. You are not bound to automatic interpretation anymore.
This moment can happen in a coffee shop. In a museum. Before an artwork. With someone. The moment is not special. The moment is available. You only need to release your automatic interpretation.
In our age of algorithms and personalized experience, we have less and less of this moment. Everything is already interpreted for you. Algorithms see for you. They assign meaning for you. You do not even have to see yourself anymore.
Artwork is an escape route. It says: you do not have to see what you think you must see. You can simply see. And in that seeing, in that moment of nausea, you feel that you are.
Sources: Jean-Paul Sartre, Nausea (1938); phenomenology (Heidegger, Merleau-Ponty)