House of Viridian
← Nourishment

Two glasses in Padua

A Bull Shot taken apart: ice-cold vodka first, lukewarm beef broth second. Why the sequence works better than the mix.

Bar Code in Padua used to have its own version of the Bull Shot: two shot glasses side by side, vodka in one, beef broth in the other, clear, without a single bead of fat. The split is the bar’s, borrowed from the strong shot with a small glass of juice behind it. The temperature is mine: the vodka from the freezer, the broth lukewarm. The cold glass first, the warm one straight after.

It is a variation on the Bull Shot, a cocktail from early-1950s Detroit: vodka, cold beef consommé, lemon, Worcestershire, Tabasco, celery salt and pepper, shaken hard and poured over ice. The original used tinned consommé, and that was a sound choice. The gelatine and salt in the tin give the drink a body that a tidy homemade stock lacks. Add tomato and it becomes a Bloody Bull, halfway to a Bloody Mary.

In Padua they take the drink apart. Anyone who knows tequila with sangrita will recognise the idea: two glasses, nothing mixed, and the second glass wipes away the first. Sangrita does it with acid and fruit. Broth does it with salt and umami, and that works harder.

Temperature does part of the work. Cold vodka numbs the tongue. Warm broth wakes it up again, and the gelatine leaves a thin coat in the mouth in which the edge of the alcohol disappears. That is why the broth should be lukewarm and never cold. In the shaken version the contrast is gone, which is exactly what I always missed in it.

Three things matter if you make it at home.

The broth has to taste right on its own. For a shaken Bull Shot you season it slightly too much, because ice and vodka dilute it. Here nothing dilutes. Use the same broth and after two rounds all you taste is salt.

Skimming is the one thing that matters. Beads of fat on lukewarm broth are the only thing that ruins this. In Padua they run it through a paper filter, which removes fat and floating particles. Cloudiness from protein stays in, and for that you would have to clarify with egg white and mince as for a true consommé. For a shot glass there is no need. Nobody holds it up to the light.

A long-simmered broth from a gelatine-rich cut of beef gives the most body. A dash of Worcestershire and a few drops of lemon in the broth are fine. I leave out the Tabasco; the vodka bites enough.

The form the bar borrowed it from, rum followed by a small glass of juice, works the same way, and mezcal with a little cup of roasted-tomato broth suggests itself. The savoury version remains the best for me, because salt and umami clear away alcohol most thoroughly.

What I like is that the drink is laid out in time instead of in the glass. You taste one thing, then another, and the third thing you taste is what they do together. A mixed cocktail only gives you the last.

If it is not on the list, you can order it almost anywhere with a kitchen behind the bar. In the Veneto there is always brodo di carne on a stove somewhere. Ask for vodka from the freezer and a small glass of brodo di manzo, tiepido, ben sgrassato.